Your Credit Still Matters at Renewal. Here’s What to Do About It.

By Andy Atchison | Founder, FairRate Canada

I’ll admit something. Before I started building a mortgage tool, I assumed credit was a buying-a-house problem. You get approved once, you move in, and nobody looks at your score again until you buy the next place.

That’s often true if you simply accept the renewal offer from your current lender. It stops being true when you want to shop around. And in my experience, the willingness to walk away from an offer gives you leverage at renewal.

What I want to help with here is simpler than boosting a score: being in good enough shape that, when the letter arrives, you could turn it down if the number’s wrong.

Why staying is easy and leaving isn’t

Your current lender already has your mortgage. It has watched you make payments for years. Renewing with the same lender often does not require a full new application, which is why signing feels painless.

The trouble is that convenience can discourage comparison shopping. A renewal offer is not necessarily the best offer available.

Moving to a new lender means applying for approval. The lender may check your credit, request proof of income and order an appraisal.

There is some good news. Since November 21, 2024, OSFI has not required its prescribed minimum qualifying rate, commonly called the mortgage stress test, for eligible uninsured straight switches between federally regulated lenders at renewal. The mortgage amount and remaining contractual amortization cannot increase. Separate rules introduced December 16, 2024 also allow certain eligible low-ratio mortgages to switch lenders without the prescribed minimum qualifying rate when portfolio insurance criteria are met. These exemptions do not guarantee approval: lenders still assess creditworthiness, income, debts and repayment capacity.

I’d start getting ready about six months before your term ends.

Six months out: read your credit report, not just your score

Both Equifax and TransUnion offer free access to your credit report, and checking your own report does not lower your score. Pull both. They do not always contain identical information, and a prospective lender may use either one.

Then go through them slowly, the way you’d check a restaurant bill that seems high. Is there an account you don’t recognize? A late payment you believe is wrong? A phone bill you settled that still shows an outstanding balance? An address that is no longer current?

If something is inaccurate, dispute it with the credit bureau and, where appropriate, the lender or creditor reporting it. Credit bureaus investigate disputes without charging a fee, but resolution times vary and not every disputed item will be changed. Starting early gives you time to gather records and follow up.

Five months out: get the card balances down

Here’s one that catches people. You can pay your Visa on time every month and still affect your credit profile if the balance reported is consistently close to the limit.

If you have room in the budget, work on reducing those balances before you shop. Don’t automatically cancel an older card just to “clean things up.” Closing it may change your available credit, utilization and credit history factors, although the impact depends on your overall file.

Four months out: avoid unnecessary new credit

The truck dealership is offering zero percent. The furniture store will knock 15% off if you open their card today.

Wait if you can.

New credit applications may result in hard inquiries, and new monthly payments can affect how a lender assesses your debt obligations. The same goes for co-signing: you may be responsible for that debt even if someone else makes the payments. Keep every payment on time through this process. Automatic minimum payments can help avoid an accidental missed due date, as long as the account has sufficient funds.

Have your papers in one place

If you’re salaried, have recent pay stubs and an employment letter available. If you’re self-employed or earn commission, lenders may request recent Notices of Assessment and other income records. Keep your latest mortgage statement, property tax information and other documents requested by the lender handy.

When a lender comes back with a competitive offer, having your documents ready can make the process much smoother.

Find out if your mortgage is insured

If you put less than 20% down when you bought, your mortgage was likely insured through CMHC, Sagen or Canada Guaranty. But your original down payment alone does not tell the whole story about the mortgage’s current insurance status.

Insurance status can affect which rates and switching options apply. Before comparing your offer with an advertised rate, ask your lender or broker whether that rate is available for your mortgage.

Three or four months out: start shopping

Some lenders let you renew early or hold a rate for a limited period. Federally regulated lenders must provide a renewal statement at least 21 days before your term ends, but waiting until then leaves little time to compare options.

Compare offers in writing, including the interest rate, term, payment schedule, prepayment privileges and other conditions. Advertised rates may depend on your credit, income, property and mortgage details. If you use a broker, ask how credit checks will be handled.

Also compare the cost of switching, not just the interest rate. Depending on your mortgage and lender, appraisal, discharge, assignment, legal or administrative fees may apply. Some lenders cover eligible switching costs. Ask for the net savings after fees before making a decision.

What if your credit is in rough shape right now?

This might not be the year you switch. Review your credit reports before talking with your current lender. Ask whether it can improve the renewal offer anyway. You might also discuss whether a shorter term makes sense, giving you another opportunity to compare lenders after you’ve had time to build a stronger payment history and lower balances. Remember that future rates and approval are never guaranteed.

If you only do one thing, pull both credit reports six months out and give yourself time to correct genuine errors. Almost everything else follows from that.

For most of us, a mortgage is the biggest debt we’ll ever carry, and renewal is one of the few times we get to renegotiate it. It would be a shame to show up without any leverage.

About the author

Andy Atchison, Founder of FairRate Canada

Andy Atchison

Founder, FairRate Canada

Andy Atchison lives in Edmonton and runs FairRate Canada, a free tool that helps Canadians check a written mortgage renewal offer against current public rate information.

Editorial note

This article is for general educational information only and is not individualized mortgage, legal or financial advice. Mortgage eligibility, lender requirements and costs vary. Credit Mentors Canada Inc. independently reviews guest submissions; the opinions expressed are the author’s.

Sources for factual review

Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions (OSFI), November 21, 2024: https://www.osfi-bsif.gc.ca/en/guidance/guidance-library/osfi-exempts-uninsured-mortgage-straight-switches-prescribed-mqr-implements-portfolio-lti-limits

Department of Finance Canada, December 2024: https://www.canada.ca/en/department-finance/news/2024/12/straight-switches-and-portfolio-insurance.html

Financial Consumer Agency of Canada, Renewing your mortgage: https://www.canada.ca/en/financial-consumer-agency/services/mortgages/renew-mortgage.html

Financial Consumer Agency of Canada, Discharging a mortgage: https://www.canada.ca/en/financial-consumer-agency/services/mortgages/mortgage-discharge.html